gravatar

erunnion

Emily Runnion

Recently Published

Document
Document
Document
Differential responses to pesticides and parasite stress are linked to bumble bee life stage
Bumble bees face numerous environmental stressors, including gut-parasite infection and exposure to agricultural fungicides. This study evaluates the interactive effects of these stressors on bumble bee (Bombus impatiens) microcolonies, focusing on colony development, worker survival, and parasite infection dynamics. Our aim in evaluating these interactions, was to determine if bees would experience synergistic negative health outcomes compared to single stressor exposures. We reared forty queenless bumble bee microcolonies, and treated them with either fungicide-contaminated pollen, inoculation with a gut parasite, both, or neither. Contrary to original expectations, we did not observe significant synergistic interactions between the two stressors, however we found that consumption of fungicide was associated with higher likelihood of gut-parasite infection, and delayed recovery from infection. Fungicide consumption was also connected to smaller workers, and smaller male offspring. We also found that gut-parasite infection was correlated with decreased pollen consumption overall, decreased worker survival, and fewer developed pupae. This study provides insights into the complexities of stressor interactions affecting bumble bees and emphasizes the importance of sublethal effects on pollinator health.
Public Synergism
Chapter 2: Pollen Consumption
Analyses performed: Repeated measures modeling time as a quadratic predictor of pollen comsumption, with the interaction of fungicide and crithidia
Chapter 2: Microcolony Health Analysis
Analyses run: Linear mixed effects (Guassian and Negative Binomial Distributions) Cox Proportional Hazards Analysis Generalized linear models (Binomial distribution; logit link function) Post-Hoc analysis ANOVA
Pollen Consumption Quadratic
LM.fit <- lmer(whole_dif~crithidia*fungicide*poly(pollen.ball.id,2)+(1|colony), data = df) LM.fit2 <- lmer(whole_dif~(crithidia+fungicide+poly(pollen.ball.id,2))^2+(1|colony), data = df) summary(LM.fit2) anova(LM.fit2, LM.fit, test = "Chi") #LM.fit2 fits better emtrends(LM.fit2,pairwise~crithidia, var = "pollen.ball.id", max.degree = 2) emtrends(LM.fit2,pairwise~fungicide, var = "pollen.ball.id", max.degree = 2) pollen.emm <- emmeans(time.quad3, ~crithidia*fungicide*time2) pollen.emm
Counts qPCR Data
Pollen Consumption
Microcolony Effects 1
Microcolony Effects
Synergism microcolony data analysis looking at brood production worker size and survival adult male health metrics and pollen consumption.
qPCR Results
disease dynamic draft 1
Consumption of pollen contaminated with field-realistic concentrations of fungicide cause sub-lethal effects in common eastern bumble bee (Bombus impatiens [Hymenoptera]: [Apidae]) microcolonies
Bumble bees are declining across the globe. Causes of this decline have been attributed to a variety of stressors, most notably, pesticides. Fungicides are a type of pesticide generally long considered to not affect bumble bees, and as a result, are often applied to flowering plants without consideration of pollinator exposure. Recent work demonstrates that fungicides have sublethal effects in bumble bees, but little is known about how much fungicide it takes to cause these sublethal effects. To address this gap in the literature, we fed microcolonies of the common eastern bumble bee (Bombus impatiens) pollen contaminated with a range of fungicide concentrations. We chose these concentrations based on the range of fungicide concentrations in pollen and nectar that were reported in the literature. We found that intermediate levels (1,500 ppb) of fungicide led to smaller adult males overall, measured by their dry weights and their relative fat values. Higher doses of fungicide (15,000 ppb) were also associated with shorter times until the first adult male emergence. Because body size and emergence timing are important aspects of bumble bee reproduction behavior, results have implications for mating success and altered life history events in bumble bees exposed to fungicide. E. N. Runnion1, J.P. Strange2, F. S. Sivakoff1 1Department of Evolution, Ecology, and Organismal Biology, The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio, USA 2Department of Entomology, The Ohio State University, 2021 Columbus, OH USA
manuscript 4
Manuscript Draft 2
Manuscript - Data Analysis
Manuscript - Collinearity Check
Drones 7.7.23
Pollen Final
Pollen consumption does not differ by treatment
Pristine Drone 6-29-23
drones updated with censored data
Pristine Analysis: Drones
Drone metrics. Need to fix colony duration to be emergence time while accounting for the colonies in which no drones emerged.
Final Pristine Analysis: Brood
Final analysis with organized steps for brood production of Pristine microcolonies from 2022
Pristine Analysis - not final, but mostly all drone data
Updated data analysis based on meeting with Frances at bee lab 6/8/2023 with the list of steps for organizing the analysis. Drone metrics.
Truncated - Emerge Time and Drone Counts
Emerge time and drone counts with artificially ended colonies and colonies with all workers dead cut out
Pollen No R 1
Pollen consumption without round 1
Brood Counts without Round 1
Brood data and counts of drones without round 1 data
Workers No Round 1
Worker mortality and dry weights without round 1 data
Drones No Round 1
Drone emergence time, radial length, relative fat, and dry weights without round 1 data
Colony Weights
Colony weight changes over time
Pollen Consumption
Pollen consumption per treatment (means)
Drone Health Metrics
Drone radial cell, relative fat, and dry weight
Brood
Brood metric counts
Workers
worker mortality as counts of workers alive at end of experiment and as proportion of time each worker survived. worker dry weights.
Drone radial length and relative fat
Drone radial length and relative fat analysis
Drone Dry Weights
Average drone dry weights per treatment, with average pollen consumption per colony held as an explanatory variable.
Pristine Summary
Brief intro to R Markdown
A short introduction to the basics of rmd files and a few tools yo can use to begin to understand them.
Class Reflection 9.6.2022
Reflection from HCS 7806, 9/06/2022. How to use R Markdown.